Scale of ethnic disparities in England and Wales’s courts exposed through new administrative data research
Uncovering inequalities hidden in criminal justice data and helping bring disparities in England and Wales into sharper focus.
ADR UK-funded research using linked administrative data revealed the true scale of ethnic disparities across the criminal justice system in England and Wales, uncovering differences between subgroups previously masked by aggregated data.
This evidence prompted the Ministry of Justice to publish disaggregated ethnicity statistics for the first time and has informed the Independent Sentencing Review and international scrutiny of racial discrimination.
The challenge
In 2017, the Lammy Review called for better evidence into why people from ethnic minority backgrounds are treated differently within the criminal justice system in England and Wales. Until recently, much of the available data grouped all ethnic minority groups together, making it difficult to understand how different communities experience the courts differently, or to identify exactly where and why disparities occur.
Without this detailed evidence, it was challenging for the government, courts and support organisations to know whether unfair treatment was happening, where in the justice process it occurred, and what could be done about it.
What the research found
Linked administrative data allowed researchers to analyse detailed court information in a way that hadn't been done before, looking separately at different ethnic minority subgroups rather than treating them as one group. This new approach revealed disparities that had previously gone unnoticed.
The research found that ethnic disproportionality exists at various stages of the justice system, and that the extent of this varies considerably between different groups, including Asian, Black, mixed, and white ethnic minority subgroups. People from ethnic minority backgrounds were more likely to be sent to the Crown Court for trial, to plead not guilty, and to be held in custody before their trial, compared with white British defendants. This disproportionality was found to be especially pronounced among young men and in drug offence cases.
While conviction rates for ethnic minority defendants were lower or similar to those for white British defendants, if convicted, they were more likely to receive a prison sentence, and the sentence would be longer.
The research showed that people from ethnic minority backgrounds can experience what researchers call ‘cumulative disadvantage’. Poorer outcomes at earlier stages, such as higher rates of pre-trial detention, are linked to harsher outcomes later on, such as longer sentences.
Crucially, even after accounting for other factors like the type and seriousness of the offence and previous convictions, disparities in remand and imprisonment remained. For example, the odds of imprisonment were 41% higher for Chinese defendants, and between 16% and 21% higher for defendants from Asian groups, compared with white British defendants. Imprisonment was also between 9% and 19% more likely for defendants from Black groups, and 22% more likely for white and Black African defendants, than for white British defendants.
Disparities in sentence length were largely explained by legal factors such as the severity of the offence, meaning that once these factors were taken into account, differences between most groups and white British defendants narrowed or disappeared. However, defendants from Pakistani, Bangladeshi and Black Caribbean backgrounds continued to receive sentences between 4% and 11% longer than white British defendants, even after adjusting for these factors.
The impact on policy and practice
This new research has directly shaped how the government measures and reports on ethnic disparities in the justice system. Following the findings, the Ministry of Justice published disaggregated ethnicity statistics for the first time in its 2024 release of Statistics on Ethnicity and the Criminal Justice System, adopting the more detailed approach used in this research and citing the findings.
The research has informed high-level policy discussions and reviews. It was discussed at a policy roundtable hosted by the Ministry of Justice and shared with the Shadow Data Governance Panel. The Deputy Senior Presiding Judge has engaged actively with the findings, with ongoing discussions about what they mean for judicial training and guidance.
The findings have also fed into national and international scrutiny of racial discrimination. In July 2024, the research featured in the Equality and Human Rights Commission's report Racial Discrimination in Great Britain, submitted as evidence to the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination. In January 2025, the research was submitted as evidence to the Independent Sentencing Review.
But this isn’t all. The research team also aimed to share their findings with public audiences too. Working with two partner organisations, CLINKS and Action for Race Equality, the research team produced a policy briefing and an illustrated data comic explaining the findings and recommendations in accessible formats. These were shared through criminal justice membership organisations, on social media, and in broadcast coverage, and the findings were reported in the Metro and the Voice newspapers, helping to bring the research to public attention beyond specialist policy audiences.
The research also improved the underlying data infrastructure used by the research community, contributing to a report that led to a change in Ministry of Justice guidance on how the datasets should be used. Training materials were also developed for postgraduate students and researchers to encourage wider use of this data in future studies, ensuring the ongoing impact from this dataset on policy and practice.
Lead Researcher: Dr Kitty Lymperopoulou, University of Plymouth
This research used data made available via the Office for National Statistics (ONS) Secure Research Service, which is being expanded and improved with ADR UK funding.
Background information and further reading
Publications and reports
Data Explained: Ethnic inequalities in the criminal justice system, August 2022
Data Insight: Ethnic Inequalities in Sentencing in the Crown Court - Evidence from the MoJ Data First Criminal Justice datasets, September 2022
Data comic: Ethnic Inequalities in the Criminal Justice System, January 2023
Policy briefing: Ethnic Inequalities in the Criminal Justice System: a briefing. By EQUAL, January 2023
Magazine article: Using administrative data to investigate ethnic inequalities in the criminal justice system, March 2023
Journal article: Ethnic Inequalities in Sentencing: Evidence from the Crown Court in England and Wales, February 2024
Data used
The study drew on the magistrates' and Crown Court datasets developed through the Ministry of Justice's Data First programme, funded by ADR UK. It also used the Indices of Deprivation 2019 (income and employment domains) and the 2020 Cambridge Crime Harm Index. These datasets form part of ADR UK's Data First: Cross-Justice System flagship dataset, which is available to accredited researchers.
Methods used
The research used disproportionality analysis with the Relative Rate Index to measure the scale of disparities between white British and ethnic minority groups. It also used multilevel modelling to examine how defendant, case and court characteristics influence outcomes, and to test whether ethnic disparities remained after accounting for these factors.
This research was funded through an ADR UK Research Fellowship (ES/V015613/1) and carried out using the ONS Secure Research Service, an accredited trusted research environment.